Comparison chart low-pressure plasma/atmospheric-pressure plasma

Applications and properties
Advantages of low-pressure plasma
Disadvantages of low-pressure plasma
Advantages of atmospheric-pressure plasma
Disadvantages of atmospheric-pressure plasma
Advantages of atmospheric plasma corona
Disadvantages of atmospheric plasma corona
Plasma generation in general
Plasma is evenly distributed inside a plasma chamber. Chamber volumes can vary from 2 to 12,000 litres.
Complex vacuum technology. In-line plasma treatment applications are limited.
Plasma treatment can be realized directly at the conveyor belt. Suitable for in-line. No vacuum technology required
The plasma treatment track is limited due to the plasma excitation principle (approx. 8-12 mm). More nozzles must be used for the treatment of larger objects
Plasma treatment can be realized directly at the conveyor belt. Suitable for in-line. No vacuum technology required. The plasma treatment width is approximately 60 mm.
Only suitable for non-conductive substrates. Relatively low treatment rate compared with atmospheric-pressure plasma
Treatment of metals
Oxidation-sensitive objects can be cleaned with plasma. (e.g. H2 as process gas)
The energy can be coupled to the objects by microwave excitation. This causes overheating of the object. With kHz plasma no overheating is observed
In plasma treatment of aluminium, very thin oxide layers (passivation) can be generated
The plasma cleaning of oxidation-sensitive objects is limited
Not possible
Treatment of polymers/elastomers
Plasma activation of PTFE is possible (etching process). Good plasma processes for elastomer and PTFE seals have been developed and are in use
Some materials (e.g. silicone) require larger pumps to achieve the required process pressure
Pretreatment of "endless" objects is possible (e.g. hoses, cables, etc.). Very short process time
Plasma jet has a temperature of approx. 200-300 °C. Process parameters must be well adapted to the surface to avoid combustion (thin materials)
Pretreatment of "endless" and wide objects (up to 60 mm) is possible
Relatively low treatment rate compared with atmospheric-pressure plasma. The treatment uniformity and the surface energy are somewhat lower in comparison with atmospheric and low-pressure plasma
3-D objects
All objects in the plasma chamber are treated equally. Even cavities can be treated from the inside (e.g. ignition coils, water tanks, etc.)
Not known
Local surface treatment is possible (e.g. adhesive groves)
Elaborate articulated robot technology is required. Gap penetration properties of atmospheric-pressure plasma is limited
Only conditionally suitable
Elaborate articulated robot technology is required. Gap penetration properties of the corona plasma is very limited
Bulk material items
Rotary drum method allows uniform plasma treatment of bulk material items. The number and volume of parts may be variable
Only 1/3 of the rotary drum volume is used (recommended)
The objects can be treated directly on the conveyor belt
The objects have to be very accurately positioned on the conveyor belt
The treatment of bulk material items in conjunction with a rotary drum is possible. The parts can be treated directly on a conveyor belt (3-dimensional)
Reduced treatment intensity compared with low-pressure plasma
Electronic/semiconductor technology
Plasma treatment of electronic components, circuit boards and semiconductor parts by means of low-pressure plasma is state of the art.
Not known
Plasma pretreatment of metal or ITO contacts must be implemented immediately before the bonding process (e.g. LCD, TFT and chip production)
Increased temperature of the plasma jet and limited gap penetration properties may limit the use of atmospheric-pressure plasma in the electronics industry
Not suitable due to high voltage potential
Coating processes
Production of uniform coatings. Many PECVD and PVD processes have been developed and are applied
Plasma chamber may be contaminated
There are many applications used in industry
There are currently no applications used in industry
There are currently no applications used in industry